Shelter Island, NY

Real Estate & Homes for Sale

  1. 36 New York Avenue
    23 photos

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House For Sale

    36 New York Avenue, NY

    $799,000

    • 2 beds
    • 1 baths
    • 968 sqft
    • 5,227 sqft lot
  2. 6 Cove Way
    Open Sat 7/9 2pm-6pm
    30 photos

    OAM.Com

    House For Sale

    6 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY

    $3,095,000

    • 3 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 2,649 sqft
    • ~1/2 acre lot
  3. 78 Peconic Avenue
    35 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    House For Sale

    78 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island, NY

    $3,250,000

    • 4 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 2,504 sqft
    • ~1/2 acre lot
  4. 29 St Marys Road
    3 photos

    Henrietta Homes & Properties

    Land For Sale

    29 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,100,000

    • beds
    • baths
    • sqft
    • ~4 acre lot
  5. 2 Southwick Lane
    17 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    House For Sale

    2 Southwick Lane, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,850,000

    • 4 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 2,601 sqft
    • ~3/4 acre lot
  6. 15 S Cartwright Road
    26 photos

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House For Sale

    15 S Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,995,000

    • 4 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 3,100 sqft
    • ~1 acre lot
  7. 2 & 4 Southwick Lane
    36 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    Multifamily For Sale

    2 & 4 Southwick Lane, Shelter Island, NY

    $2,950,000

    • 6 beds
    • 6 baths
    • 4,315 sqft
    • ~2 acre lot
  8. 9 W Neck Road
    3 photos

    Signature Premier Properties

    Land For Sale

    9 W Neck Road, NY

    $1,199,000

    • beds
    • baths
    • sqft
    • ~3 acre lot
  9. 44 St Marys Road
    25 photos

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House For Sale

    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $4,750,000

    • 3 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 3,225 sqft
    • ~8 acre lot
  10. 15 S Midway Road
    14 photos

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House For Sale

    15 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,049,000

    • 4 beds
    • 3 baths
    • 2,144 sqft
    • ~1 acre lot
  11. 9 S Midway Road
    14 photos

    Karen O Connolly

    House For Sale

    9 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,900,000

    • 4 beds
    • 2 baths
    • 1,672 sqft
    • ~3/4 acre lot
  12. 23 Great Circle Drive
    29 photos

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    House For Sale

    23 Great Circle Drive, Shelter Island, NY

    $2,600,000

    • 6 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 4,090 sqft
    • ~1 acre lot
  13. 72 S Ferry Road
    32 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    House For Sale

    72 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,975,000

    • 1 beds
    • 1 baths
    • 1,800 sqft
    • ~6 acre lot
  14. 82 N Cartwright Road
    29 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    House For Sale

    82 N Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,875,000

    • 4 beds
    • 3 baths
    • sqft
    • ~3/4 acre lot
  15. 101 S Ferry Road
    35 photos

    Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    House For Sale

    101 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY

    $1,699,000

    • 8 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 3,098 sqft
    • ~1 acre lot
  • End of Results
  • No homes match your search. Try resetting your search criteria.

    Reset search