1 of 5

Want to see this home?

553 Lilley Hill Road

Butternuts, NY 13849

4 beds
3 baths
1,404 sqft
~5 acre lot
$192 per sqft
2006 build
– on site

Welcome to 553 Lilley Hill Road, a private Cape Cod-style retreat nestled on 4.91 secluded acres in scenic Unadilla. This spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers over 1,400 square feet of warm, functional living space and is perfect for those who crave peace, privacy, and modern comfort. Step inside to warm, welcoming living room featuring hardwood floors and a cozy wood-burning fireplace—ideal for entertaining or relaxing at home. The updated kitchen is a chef’s dream with stainless-steel appliances, a large walnut butcher-block island, and direct access to a new covered back deck with recessed lighting. Two bedrooms and a full bath on the first floor offer convenient layout options, while two spacious second-floor suites—each with its own full bath and walk-in closet—provide privacy and flexibility. The finished basement expands your options with bonus living space, barn-style sliding doors, and a spacious laundry room. Enjoy nature from your new front porch or explore the wooded acreage filled with birdsong and wildlife. This home includes a whole-house generator and is just minutes from the charm of Unadilla, Gilbertsville, and Cooperstown. Move-in ready and full of character—this is the Upstate lifestyle you’ve been looking for.

Listing courtesy of NYSAMLS / Howard Hanna Cny Inc

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Jul 14, 2025 •

MLS# S1616850 —

The Building

Year Built:

2006
Year Built Details:

Existing
Builder Model:

Na
Construction Materials:

VinylSiding,CopperPlumbing,PexPlumbing
Architectural Style:

CapeCod,ModularPrefab
Roof:

Asphalt,Shingle
Basement:

Full,Finished,SumpPump
Basement:

true
Foundation Details:

Poured
Exterior Features:

Deck,GravelDriveway,PropaneTankOwned
Patio And Porch Features:

Deck
Green Energy Efficient:

Appliances,Lighting
Building Area Total:

1404.0
Building Area Source:

PublicRecords

Interior

Rooms Total:

8
Interior Features:

EatInKitchen,SeparateFormalLivingRoom,CountryKitchen,KitchenIsland,NaturalWoodwork,BedroomOnMainLevel
Flooring:

Carpet,Hardwood,LuxuryVinyl,Varies
Fireplace:

true
Fireplaces Total:

1
Laundry Features:

InBasement
Stories Total:

1

Room Dimensions

Living Area:

1,404 Sqft

Location

Directions:

From Unadilla, take Bridge St over the river, left on Sheep Pen Rd, then right on Lilley Hill Rd. From I-88 Exit 10, follow NY-7 to Bridge St, then follow same. Home is ~10 min from I-88, 25 min from Oneonta, 20 from Sidney.

The Property

Property Type:

Residential
Property Subtype:

SingleFamilyResidence
Property Condition:

Resale
Parcel Number:

362289-295-000-0001-003-003-0000
Lot Features:

IrregularLot,RuralLot,Wooded
Lot Size Dimensions:

357X612
Lot Size Acres:

4.91
Lot Size SqFt:

213880.0
Lot Size Area:

4.91
Lot Size Units:

Acres
Waterfront:

false
Water Body Name:

NA
Other Equipment:

Generator,SatelliteDish
Other Structures:

Sheds,Storage

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Tax Lot:

3
Tax Annual Amount:

3291.0
Tax Assessed Value:

168500

Beds

Bedrooms Total:

4
Main Level Bedrooms:

2

Baths

Total Baths:

3
Full Baths:

3
Main Level Baths:

1

The Listing

Virtual Tour URL Unbranded:

https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/syr/S1616850

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Gas,Wood,Baseboard
Heating:

true

Utilities

Utilities:

ElectricityConnected
Electric:

CircuitBreakers
Sewer:

SepticTank
Water Source:

Well

Appliances

Appliances:

Dryer,Dishwasher,GasOven,GasRange,GasWaterHeater,Microwave,Refrigerator,Washer

Schools

Elementary School District:

Gilbertsville-Mount Upton
Middle Or Junior School District:

Gilbertsville-Mount Upton
High School:

Gilbertsville Mount Upton Junior Senior High
High School District:

Gilbertsville-Mount Upton

The Community

Subdivision Name:

NA

Parking

Garage:

false
Parking Features:

NoGarage,Driveway,Other

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$270,000

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$1,445
Taxes	$274
Insurance	$74
Utilities	$240 See report
Total	$2,033/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price	% Change
7/3/25 Jul 3, 2025	Sold Subject To Contingencies	NYSAMLS	$270,000
6/20/25 Jun 20, 2025	Listed / Active	NYSAMLS	$270,000	394.5% (49.3% / YR)
6/20/17 Jun 20, 2017		NYSAMLS	$54,600

Want a closer look?

Go see 553 Lilley Hill Road

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-258-2512

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in Butternuts, NY

Similar sold homes

This house located in Butternuts, NY 13849 is currently for sale for $270,000. 553 Lilley Hill Road is a 1,404 square foot house with 4 beds and 3 baths that has been on Estately for 24 days. This house is in the attendance area of Gilbertsville-Mount Upton Junior-Senior High School and Gilbertsville-Mount Upton Elementary School.

This site was last updated on 07/14/2025. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal.