Looking for the perfect waterfront property with unmatched flexibility and value? 36 Emily Lane stands out as San Carlos Island’s crown jewel—and here’s why: It offers direct Gulf access via a deep water canal and is located near the end of the street, allowing you to build your own private boat dock. With no height restrictions and minimal setback requirements, you have the freedom to design and build the custom coastal home you’ve always dreamed of, with more buildable space. You own the land outright—no land lease—and it’s the only street in the subdivision with central water and sewer, a rare and valuable upgrade. There are no pet restrictions, both short and long term rentals are allowed, it’s not a 55+ community, and HOA fees are just $55/month! Build with confidence—in 2022, the soil was professionally stabilized with polyurethane grout by Stable Soils to ensure land and seawall support. The seawall also received all new vents, and a new patio was installed that same year! Emily Lane offers better walkability to restaurants, Salty Sam's Marina (with more marinas under construction), and the Key West Express, all right at the start of the street. You can walk over the bridge to the beach without dealing with traffic, and enjoy a more affordable, less congested version of the same coastal lifestyle. Schedule a Private Showing

Listing courtesy of FGCMLS / John R Wood Properties

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated May 17, 2025 • Source: FGCMLS

MLS# 224049707 — Report a problem

This property is listed in more than one place. See it here.