1 of 50

Want to see this home?

3092 Route 89

Fayette, NY 13148

4 beds
3 baths
3,806 sqft
1 sqft lot
$364 per sqft
1820 build
– on site

Welcome to The Garnsey on Cayuga Lake — a truly exceptional lakefront retreat that blends timeless charm with modern luxury. Originally rich in history, this stunning property was completely reimagined and rebuilt from the ground up in 2019. Set on over an acre of beautifully maintained grounds with more than 130 feet of direct lake frontage, this estate boasts great outdoor living spaces, a dock, and panoramic views of Cayuga Lake that stretch for miles. Spanning over 3,800 square feet of total living space, including an 850-square-foot finished bonus area above the garage, this home is designed with lifestyle and functionality in mind. Step inside through the side entry and you’ll be welcomed by a spacious mudroom and laundry area—complete with built-in cabinetry and a convenient dog-wash station—ideal for cleaning up after a day on the water or exploring the nearby Finger Lakes trails. The heart of the home is the chef’s kitchen, featuring a large custom island, high-end appliances, and ample storage. It flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, which offers plenty of space for entertaining large groups or intimate dinners with friends and family. Just off the kitchen, the center hall entry leads to a spacious living room and out to the expansive covered front porch, where you’ll enjoy unobstructed views of the lake from sunrise to sunset. The main-floor primary bedroom is a peaceful retreat, complete with dramatic vaulted ceilings and a picturesque picture window framing lake views. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized guest bedrooms, both with walk-in closets, along with a beautifully appointed full bathroom. The primary suite upstairs is a true sanctuary, boasting a luxurious spa-like bathroom with double vanity, tiled walk-in shower, and a massive walk-in closet. From the second-floor covered balcony, you can enjoy elevated views of the lake and soak in the serenity of waterfront living. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence, a seasonal escape, or a luxury short-term rental opportunity, The Garnsey on Cayuga Lake offers it all—privacy, elegance, and prime access to the best the Finger Lakes have to offer. Offered fully furnished!

Listing courtesy of NYSAMLS / Century 21 Steve Davoli RE

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Jun 10, 2025 •

MLS# R1613904 —

The Building

Year Built:

1820
Year Built Details:

Existing
Construction Materials:

VinylSiding,CopperPlumbing
Architectural Style:

Colonial,HistoricAntique
Roof:

Asphalt
Basement:

Full
Basement:

true
Foundation Details:

Block,Stone
Exterior Features:

Balcony,Dock,GravelDriveway,SeeRemarks
Window Features:

ThermalWindows
Patio And Porch Features:

Balcony,Open,Porch
Levels:

Two
Building Area Total:

3806.0
Building Area Source:

Other

Interior

Rooms Total:

14
Furnished:

Furnished
Interior Features:

CathedralCeilings,SeparateFormalDiningRoom,EntranceFoyer,EatInKitchen,Furnished,SeparateFormalLivingRoom,GraniteCounters,BedroomOnMainLevel
Flooring:

CeramicTile,Hardwood,Varies
Fireplace:

false
Laundry Features:

MainLevel
Stories:

2
Stories Total:

2

Room Dimensions

Living Area:

3,806 Sqft

Location

Directions:

NYS Route 89 South, approximately 5 miles south of the state park. Home sits on the West side of Rt. 89 and is approximately 3/4 mile south of Noble Rd

The Property

Property Type:

Residential
Property Subtype:

SingleFamilyResidence
Property Condition:

Resale
Parcel Number:

452289-008-000-0001-004-122-0000
Lot Features:

Rectangular,RectangularLot
Lot Size Dimensions:

135X0
Lot Size Acres:

1.1
Lot Size Area:

1.1
Lot Size Units:

Acres
Frontage Length:

135
Waterfront:

true
Waterfront Features:

Lake
Water Body Name:

Cayuga Lake
Road Frontage Type:

MainThoroughfare

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Tax Annual Amount:

9133.0
Tax Assessed Value:

225100

Beds

Bedrooms Total:

4
Main Level Bedrooms:

1

Baths

Total Baths:

3
Full Baths:

2
Half Baths:

1
Main Level Baths:

1

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Propane,ForcedAir
Heating:

true
Cooling:

CentralAir
Cooling:

true

Utilities

Utilities:

CableAvailable,HighSpeedInternetAvailable,WaterConnected
Electric:

CircuitBreakers
Sewer:

SepticTank
Water Source:

Connected,Public

Appliances

Appliances:

Dryer,Dishwasher,ElectricWaterHeater,GasOven,GasRange,Refrigerator,Washer

Schools

Elementary School District:

Seneca Falls
Middle Or Junior School District:

Seneca Falls
High School District:

Seneca Falls

The Community

Subdivision Name:

Late West Cayuga Reservat

Parking

Garage:

true
Garage Spaces:

2.0
Attached Garage:

true
Parking Features:

Attached,Garage,Storage,Driveway,GarageDoorOpener

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$1,389,000

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$7,437
Taxes	$761
Insurance	$381
Utilities	$299 See report
Total	$8,878/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Soundscore™

Provided by HowLoud

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price	% Change
6/10/25 Jun 10, 2025	Listed / Active	NYSAMLS	$1,389,000	1077.1% (158.9% / YR)
7/2/24 Jul 2, 2024	Listed / Active	NYSAMLS
8/31/18 Aug 31, 2018		NYSAMLS	$118,000

Want a closer look?

Go see 3092 Route 89

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-258-2512

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in Fayette, NY

Similar sold homes

This house located in Fayette, NY 13148 is currently for sale for $1,389,000. 3092 Route 89 is a 3,806 square foot house with 4 beds and 3 baths that has been on Estately for 5 days. This house is in the attendance area of Frank Knight Elementary School, Elizabeth Cady Stanton School, Mynderse Academy, and Seneca Falls Middle School.

This site was last updated on 06/15/2025. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal.