1 of 50

Want to see this home?

2756 Coates Road

Jerusalem, NY 14527

6 beds
7 baths
4,320 sqft
~12 acre lot
$185 per sqft
1822 build
– on site

**RARE OPPORTUNITY to Own a Piece of History w/This Beautifully Restored & Meticulously Maintained 1822 Historic Colonial Home Situated on 12.36 Acres Overlooking Picturesque Keuka Lake! Welcome to 2756 Coates Rd. This Home was once a part of the Underground Railroad & has had only 3 Owners. So Many Possibilities w/This Property, operated for decades as the Merritt Hill Manor Bed and Breakfast. This 6 Bedroom, 6.5 Bath Home Boasts Over 4,300 Sq Ft of Living Space w/Both Historical Charm & Modern Touches. Original Hardwoods, Woodwork, Molding & Built-ins Throughout! Step Into the Large Entryway w/Cozy Nook Underneath Ornate Curved Staircase. Oversized Chef’s Kitchen has Been Updated & Expanded to Feature Huge Island w/Bar Seating, Double Ovens, Gas Cooktop, Corian Countertops, Abundant Storage w/Butler’s Pantry …Perfect for Entertaining! Powder Room off Butler’s Pantry. French Doors Lead to Family Room w/Gas FP & Library. Back Staircase Leads to what was used as the Owner’s Quarters but could be a Rec room, or teen suite. Large Formal Dining Room w/Built-ins & Sitting Area. French Doors Open to Light Filled Living has Alcove w/Built-ins. Spacious 1st Floor Bedroom & Full Bath Offer Convenience and would make a beautiful Primary Suite. 2nd Floor Features Sitting Area, 5 Generously Sized Bedrooms Each w/Their Own En-Suite Bath & 2nd Floor Laundry. Newer Windows & Roof! On Demand Hot Water! Attached 2 Car Garage. Paver Path Leads to Restored Carriage House & Huge Stable w/ 3 Horse Stalls & ample space. Perfect for Equine Enthusiasts! Property Also Includes a small parcel on the other Side of Coates Rd. Enjoy all That the Finger Lakes & Keuka Lake Area Have to Offer…This is a MUST SEE! No Delayed Negotiations.

Listing courtesy of NYSAMLS / Keller Williams Realty Gateway

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Jun 9, 2025 •

MLS# R1610424 —

The Building

Year Built:

1822
Year Built Details:

Existing
Construction Materials:

VinylSiding,CopperPlumbing
Architectural Style:

Colonial,HistoricAntique
Roof:

Asphalt
Basement:

Full
Basement:

true
Foundation Details:

Stone
Exterior Features:

BlacktopDriveway,PropaneTankLeased
Window Features:

Drapes
Levels:

Two
Building Area Total:

4320.0
Building Area Source:

PublicRecords

Interior

Rooms Total:

19
Furnished:

Partially
Interior Features:

BreakfastBar,Den,SeparateFormalDiningRoom,EntranceFoyer,EatInKitchen,SeparateFormalLivingRoom,GuestAccommodations,KitchenIsland,Pantry,PartiallyFurnished,NaturalWoodwork,WindowTreatments,BedroomOnMainLevel,BathInPrimaryBedroom,MainLevelPrimary,PrimarySuite,Workshop
Flooring:

Hardwood,Tile,Varies,Vinyl
Fireplace:

true
Fireplaces Total:

1
Laundry Features:

UpperLevel
Stories:

2
Stories Total:

2

Room Dimensions

Living Area:

4,320 Sqft

The Property

Property Type:

Residential
Property Subtype:

SingleFamilyResidence
Property Condition:

Resale
Parcel Number:

572689-072-001-0001-016-000-0000
Lot Features:

Agricultural,IrregularLot,Wooded
Lot Size Dimensions:

675X1008
Lot Size Acres:

12.36
Lot Size SqFt:

538402.0
Lot Size Area:

12.36
Lot Size Units:

Acres
View:

true
View:

Water
Waterfront:

false
Waterfront Features:

Lake
Water Body Name:

Keuka Lake
Other Structures:

Barns,Outbuilding,Other
Horse:

true
Horse Amenities:

HorsesAllowed

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Tax Lot:

16
Tax Annual Amount:

9420.0
Tax Assessed Value:

721600

Beds

Bedrooms Total:

6
Main Level Bedrooms:

1

Baths

Total Baths:

7
Full Baths:

6
Half Baths:

1
Main Level Baths:

2

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Propane,Baseboard,HotWater
Heating:

true
Cooling:

AtticFan

Utilities

Utilities:

CableAvailable,HighSpeedInternetAvailable
Electric:

CircuitBreakers
Sewer:

SepticTank
Water Source:

Well

Appliances

Appliances:

ConvectionOven,DoubleOven,Dryer,Dishwasher,ExhaustFan,Disposal,GasOven,GasRange,Microwave,PropaneWaterHeater,Refrigerator,RangeHood,TanklessWaterHeater,Washer,WaterPurifierOwned,WaterSoftenerOwned

Schools

Elementary School:

Penn Yan Elementary
Elementary School District:

Penn Yan
Middle Or Junior School:

Penn Yan Middle
Middle Or Junior School District:

Penn Yan
High School:

Penn Yan Academy
High School District:

Penn Yan

The Community

Senior Community:

false

Parking

Garage:

true
Garage Spaces:

2.0
Attached Garage:

true
Parking Features:

Attached,Garage,Driveway

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$799,900

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$4,283
Taxes	$785
Insurance	$219
Utilities	$343 See report
Total	$5,630/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Max Internet Speed

Spectrum

Provided by BroadbandNow®

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price
6/9/25 Jun 9, 2025	Listed / Active	NYSAMLS	$799,900
8/6/24 Aug 6, 2024	Price Changed	NYSAMLS
5/21/24 May 21, 2024	Listed / Active	NYSAMLS

Want a closer look?

Go see 2756 Coates Road

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-258-2512

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in Jerusalem, NY

Similar sold homes

This house located in Jerusalem, NY 14527 is currently for sale for $799,900. 2756 Coates Road is a 4,320 square foot house with 6 beds and 7 baths that has been on Estately for 9 days. This house is in the attendance area of Penn Yan Academy, Penn Yan Elementary School, and Penn Yan Middle School.

This site was last updated on 06/18/2025. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal.